Carrier Comparisons

Compare Insurance Carriers

Bright Coast Insurance is an independent agency appointed with Florida's top carriers. These comparisons are written from the perspective of an agent who writes business with the carriers on both sides — so you get an honest assessment, not a sales pitch.

Workers' Compensation

Florida workers' comp carrier comparisons for contractors and employers.

Frank Winston Crum vs. Employers Holdings→Frank Winston Crum vs. FWCJUA (State Fund)→Frank Winston Crum vs. AmTrust→Frank Winston Crum vs. biBERK→

General Liability — Contractors

GL carrier comparisons for Florida contractors, roofers, and tradespeople.

CBIC vs. Next Insurance→CBIC vs. Hiscox→Frank Winston Crum vs. Next Insurance (GL)→

Commercial Trucking Insurance

Trucking insurance carrier comparisons for Florida owner-operators and fleets.

Progressive vs. Sentry Trucking→Progressive vs. National Interstate→

Commercial Auto Insurance

Commercial auto carrier comparisons for Florida business vehicles.

Berkshire Hathaway GUARD vs. Travelers→

Personal Auto — Standard

Personal auto carrier comparisons for Florida drivers with clean records.

GEICO vs. State Farm→GEICO vs. Allstate→GEICO vs. Nationwide→

Personal Auto — High Risk / Nonstandard

Nonstandard auto carrier comparisons for Florida drivers needing SR-22 or FR-44.

Bristol West vs. Dairyland→Bristol West vs. The General→

Florida Homeowners Insurance

Florida homeowners carrier comparisons — private market vs. Citizens.

Slide Insurance vs. Citizens→Security First vs. Citizens→

PEO Services

Professional Employer Organization comparisons for Florida small businesses.

Encore HR vs. Paychex PEO→Key HR vs. ADP TotalSource→

Not Sure Which Carrier Is Right for You?

Bright Coast Insurance shops multiple carriers on your behalf and recommends the best fit for your specific situation — not just the cheapest option.

Get a Free Quote